If you're meandering through Salem and find yourself craving authentic New York-style pizza, look no further than Straight From New York Pizza, located at 233 Liberty St NE. This cozy pizza haven has garnered a loyal following for its delightful slices and welcoming atmosphere. As a food reviewer for Foodjoyy, I can confidently share that this is not just another pizza place—it’s a slice of New York brought to the West Coast.

Imagine walking into a charming establishment that exudes the warmth of a classic New York pizzeria. The ambiance described by customers evokes images of a slightly dingy, yet endearing place, where the aroma of freshly baked pizza greets you at the door. It's the kind of spot where you can comfortably enjoy a slice or two, whether inside or alfresco, all made in the spirit of simplicity and flavor.

Numerous patrons, including locals and transplants from the East Coast, have raved about the authenticity and quality of the pizza here. One reviewer, AJ D., notes, "This is some of the best, most similar to NY-style pizza I’ve tried on the west coast!" The thin crust is consistently praised for its perfect crispness, striking a balance between crunch and chew, while toppings are plentiful and delicious. The extra touches, like having red pepper flakes and oregano on hand, elevate the experience, ensuring that each flavor is perfectly complemented.

The charm of Straight From New York Pizza lies not just in its delectable offerings, but also in its commitment to customer comfort and satisfaction. Frequent visitors are drawn back not only for the food but for the friendly service. The establishment is known for being humble and down-to-earth, which resonates with patrons seeking a genuine dining experience away from the glitz of trendier spots. W.J. R. emphasizes this sentiment, indicating that it’s the friendliness that keeps them coming back.

Another highlight is the availability of pizza by the slice, perfect for those looking for a quick yet delicious meal. Add to that their accommodating seating options, and you have a community hub that invites everyone—from families to busy professionals—for a moment of respite and indulgence. Anna Landgren, a devoted fan for over a decade, expresses her love for the crunchy-yet-tender crust and even delights in the quirky addition of honey for drizzling on the crust, exemplifying the establishment's unique touch.

In summary, Straight From New York Pizza (Downtown Salem) is more than just a pizza shop; it’s a cherished local gem that expertly captures the essence of a classic New York pizzeria while providing a cozy retreat in the heart of Salem. Whether you’re a lifelong pizza lover or just curious to explore, this spot promises a memorable dining experience that embodies a true love for great food.